托盘专用论文方法 · 最新标注对比 v5

冻结时间 2026-10-21T16:12:18+00:00 · train 1767 / val 667 / test 1159

独立论文适配实现,不冒充作者原实现。 主对照输入相同:原检测框内有序XYZ;无人工选面、标尺或掩膜输入。全部输出不可下发机器人。
下载 target_metrics.csv 下载 comparison_data.json 

原train分组CV

原train CV候选阈值m组等权分↓失败数
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版0.00850.324986984
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版0.01557.7020391053
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版0.02563.6688471102
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版0.0080.9708835
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版0.0151.06330016
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版0.0251.97506030
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版0.0155.51818482
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)0.0155.72354490

冻结后的test完整分母

方案位置均值mm↓*中位数mm↓P90mm↓P95mm↓方向均值°↓*方向P90°↓输出/总数达标/总数挽回新增退化共同输出Δ位置mm
现有几何+ROI回退13.9222.22625.01846.5830.6370.3111159/11591099/1159000.000
现有纯几何(失败不回退)13.6862.08424.00045.4230.6210.2851151/11591095/1159040.000
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版276.379242.476577.470643.83128.40290.919434/115982/115941021255.797
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版+共同几何回退109.7086.887316.321557.59710.82561.2541159/1159779/1159432495.786
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版25.8959.66159.58796.9980.5470.8921158/1159998/11594614711.962
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版+共同几何回退25.8739.65459.58696.9620.5470.8911159/1159999/11594614611.952
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版112.25176.589271.214291.7898.40030.1581074/1159344/11591577098.213
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版+共同几何回退104.93269.886269.615289.7087.79329.8391159/1159426/11591568891.010
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)117.29378.883277.453306.1848.80030.2201077/1159353/115916762104.073
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)+共同几何回退110.63170.268274.195303.8938.34829.8991159/1159429/11591668696.709
PointNeXt 最新标签重训13.3975.92423.56946.0500.9931.5011159/11591096/11591215-0.525
PointNeXt v4冻结迁移(非本轮重训)13.4312.88524.57450.3420.7030.4241159/11591094/115938-0.490

val补充

方案位置均值mm↓*中位数mm↓P90mm↓P95mm↓方向均值°↓*方向P90°↓输出/总数达标/总数挽回新增退化共同输出Δ位置mm
现有几何+ROI回退8.2981.40422.77442.6580.2920.267667/667641/667000.000
现有纯几何(失败不回退)7.9871.30121.81039.2910.1000.257663/667641/667000.000
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版268.935180.614612.443644.49525.01888.487260/66770/6675576256.774
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版+共同几何回退108.3906.250484.209602.8179.99948.924667/667468/6675178100.092
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版29.25911.43580.864122.6700.4671.059665/667565/667149020.954
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版+共同几何回退29.18911.39580.765122.6280.4651.059667/667567/667148820.891
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版90.46936.101205.214262.0054.57911.025647/667376/667426982.367
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版+共同几何回退88.19535.229203.140260.8644.44810.678667/667395/667425079.897
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)83.54835.154188.753256.0094.42311.147648/667379/667526775.152
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)+共同几何回退81.30933.555168.599254.1384.30410.912667/667398/667524873.011
PointNeXt 最新标签重训12.4463.69030.01757.4900.4320.967667/667615/66710364.148
PointNeXt v4冻结迁移(非本轮重训)10.9322.60732.99850.2600.3880.411667/667632/66710192.634

配对差值与区间

test方案组等权Δ综合分描述性95%区间
现有几何+ROI回退0.000000[0.0, 0.0]
现有纯几何(失败不回退)1.081021[0.0, 3.243062608373609]
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版61.656509[48.403544608920576, 74.15773664091506]
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版+共同几何回退2.006505[1.1966614087390601, 2.9521116642426275]
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版0.585016[0.35834952574817286, 0.8363419182642875]
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版+共同几何回退0.534976[0.3277094504968603, 0.7672174381797897]
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版3.186957[1.9075059648021375, 4.72635652039899]
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版+共同几何回退1.786762[1.2564073423371538, 2.349189123388931]
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)3.628334[2.025376281793017, 5.424869509337456]
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)+共同几何回退1.805750[1.1841851969137451, 2.500493154141324]
PointNeXt 最新标签重训0.027061[-0.005705023897104293, 0.06191210452853444]
PointNeXt v4冻结迁移(非本轮重训)0.000715[-0.0218828624225662, 0.01957124065591331]

原生失败原因

test原生方法失败原因数量
现有纯几何(失败不回退)no_automatic_front_face8
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版no_compatible_structure_template651
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版no_region_growing_front_plane67
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版template_similarity_below_threshold7
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版invalid_front_plane1
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版registration_failed:ICP_rejected_alignment66
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版invalid_front_plane19
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)registration_failed:ICP_rejected_alignment62
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)invalid_front_plane19
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)registration_failed:ICP_rejected_alignment;SAC_IA_no_valid_hypothesis1

运行成本(非独立实时基准)

test方案共享准备/推理P50ms*P95ms*
现有几何+ROI回退——
现有纯几何(失败不回退)——
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版35.59862.629
Xiao 2017 平面结构模板 · 适配版+共同几何回退35.60959.435
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版3.2844.417
PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版+共同几何回退3.2844.418
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版579.067897.796
Shao 2023 AGWF配准 · 适配版+共同几何回退592.308902.304
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)579.005895.682
FPFH配准消融(非额外论文)+共同几何回退590.820899.767
PointNeXt 最新标签重训——
PointNeXt v4冻结迁移(非本轮重训)——

复现与解释边界

典型案例:PILA 2021 固定框几何后端 · 适配版+共同几何回退

绿色=研究标签,橙色=几何,紫色=论文适配方法;原方法失败时紫色代表共同回退。箭头方向按真实数值绘制。

挽回 · 1c5605c2347311ccd4dde632

2023_6_28/scene/7

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态-0.281.082.453.815.17-1.32-0.82-0.320.180.68X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-582-2910291582-582-2910291582dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何475.5703.212False
论文适配方法+共同回退6.9650.140True

挽回 · 2e7d229cee4565d4d328a096

2023_6_28/scene/7

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态2.012.372.733.103.46-0.75-0.43-0.110.210.53X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-329-1640164329-329-1640164329dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何246.0000.000False
论文适配方法+共同回退1.2020.130True

新增退化 · 6a6309aca9544a8b224e8796

2023_12_6/scene/300mm/2600mm

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态2.522.883.243.613.97-1.41-0.85-0.290.270.83X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-449-2250225449-449-2250225449dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何0.0000.000True
论文适配方法+共同回退333.5680.141False

新增退化 · 6321cb3d846591a99419774c

2023_12_6/scene/yaw/2700mm

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态2.512.953.393.834.28-1.43-0.87-0.310.250.80X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-475-2380238475-475-2380238475dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何25.1071.267True
论文适配方法+共同回退353.0681.110False

双方失败 · 8aca241675514cddaa313bed

2023_6_28/scene/7

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态2.122.412.713.003.290.240.390.540.690.84X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-589-2950295589-589-2950295589dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何467.30289.516False
论文适配方法+共同回退55.2120.185False

双方失败 · 7e8b00aa3e95939ae30d6a9f

2023_6_28/scene/7

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态2.142.613.083.544.010.440.520.610.700.79X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-355-1780178355-355-1780178355dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何263.5626.860False
论文适配方法+共同回退71.55777.587False

原生失败/回退 · 123a4e0b18b9a11f4a305ba7

2023_7_18/scene/1900mm

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态1.732.022.302.592.88-0.97-0.66-0.35-0.040.27X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-12-60612-12-60612dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何0.4310.054True
论文适配方法+共同回退0.4310.054True

位置改善 · 37f5402241befbdbc18d8f36

2023_6_28/scene/7

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态1.612.062.522.973.42-0.74-0.42-0.100.220.54X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-314-1570157314-314-1570157314dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何246.1040.000False
论文适配方法+共同回退2.5770.148True

位置改善 · e782e7d47abd64acf1f3ba0f

2023_6_28/scene/7

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态0.981.522.072.623.17-0.76-0.41-0.070.270.62X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-327-1630163327-327-1630163327dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何247.3010.000False
论文适配方法+共同回退4.2720.379True

位置退化 · 2c40a3b02c82c2c7443f9882

2023_12_6/scene/yaw/2700mm

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态2.622.993.363.744.11-1.09-0.500.100.691.29X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-435-2170217435-435-2170217435dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何0.0000.000True
论文适配方法+共同回退322.4140.042False

位置退化 · b7bae88276a7e0295aa98db8

2023_7_18/scene/1900mm

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态1.621.942.272.602.92-0.280.040.360.681.00X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-380-1900190380-380-1900190380dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何3.2380.023True
论文适配方法+共同回退298.2886.026False

其余稳定/失败对照 · 0012bb42474000ca70805d48

2023_11_29/scene/o3d

原强度图及原检测框,未投影姿态1.872.082.292.492.70-0.52-0.240.040.310.59X [m]Y [m]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length-12-60612-12-60612dX [mm]dY [mm]equal scale; direction arrows = fixed visual length
方案位置mm方向°达标
几何0.0000.000True
论文适配方法+共同回退8.9122.028True